1
Fish nor Fowl
4.3New American · $$$ · 5523 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206
A plant-filled, sunlit room with assured cooking. Polished, though occasionally pricey for the portions.
Order: Greenhouse-cool seasonal plates
Full review →On the mapGarfield
The 3 best restaurants in Garfield
Updated August 2026 · 3 spots reviewed
Garfield has 3 spots on the map, from american to new american. The one to book first is Fish nor Fowl.
Every rating below is one critic's 1 to 5, scored on food, vibe, value and service. Fish nor Fowl leads at 4.3. Nobody paid to be here.
- Spots
- 3
- Avg rating
- 3.8
- Highest rated
- 4.3
- Fish nor Fowl
- Cuisines
- 5
Garfield tops these boards
2
Spak Brothers
3.7Pizza, Vegan · $ · 5107 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Punk-rock pizza counter that has been quietly feeding vegans and their sceptical friends for years. Order by the slice, eat it on the curb, and don't be surprised when the vegan one is the better pie.
Order: A vegan slice that fools carnivores
Full review →On the map3
Moonlit Burgers
3.3Burgers, American · $ · 5491 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15206
Moved into the Primanti's that quit Penn Ave, which is its own kind of statement. Lacy-edged smash patties, zero ceremony, gone in ten minutes flat - the best cheap lunch in Garfield.
Order: The double smash
Full review →On the mapNearby neighborhoods
Where Garfield spills into next.
Every neighborhood
DowntownStrip DistrictLawrencevilleSquirrel HillBloomfieldEast LibertyShadysideSouth SideNorth SideOaklandMt. WashingtonMt. LebanonBeechviewHomewoodMillvale
Explore the whole map