Updated August 2026 · 10 ranked

The best pizza in Pittsburgh

Every pizzeria on the map, ranked by the same 1-5 score as everything else. Detroit squares, Neapolitan rounds and bakery cuts compete on one board, because that is how you actually choose on a Friday.

  1. 1

    Oakland · $$$ · No. 12 of 157 overall

    A Forbes Five-Star chef came home and picked pizza as the hill to die on. Three-day dough, blistered and structurally serious - proof a hotel restaurant can be the whole reason you drive to Oakland.

    Order: The 72-hour dough pizza

  2. 2

    Strip District · $$ · No. 24 of 157 overall

    Some of the best Detroit-style squares in town. Pepperoni cups, crispy edges. Casual and very good.

    Order: Detroit square with pepperoni cups

  3. 3

    Lawrenceville · $$ · No. 28 of 157 overall

    Sourdough pizza from people who clearly obsess over dough. The menu and hours are limited. Quality over breadth.

    Order: Soppressata & hot honey sourdough pie

  4. 4

    Shadyside · $$ · No. 40 of 157 overall

    Honest Neapolitan pizza and excellent house gelato. Small and busy. The cones alone justify a stop.

    Order: Neapolitan pies + made-in-house gelato

  5. 5

    Squirrel Hill · $ · No. 44 of 157 overall

    The other half of the Murray Ave pizza rivalry. Good, classic, and best argued about with a Mineo's slice in hand.

    Order: 16-inch pepperoni pizza

  6. 6

    Strip District · $ · No. 46 of 157 overall

    Strip District bakery counter doing tomato pie the old way: room temperature, heavy on the sauce, no cheese to speak of. Buy more than you think you need.

    Order: A square of tomato pie

  7. 7

    Squirrel Hill · $ · No. 62 of 157 overall

    A beloved square-slice institution. It's nostalgia pizza. Comforting and consistent, not life-changing. Pick your side in the Murray Ave war.

    Order: Square cheese slice

  8. 8

    Lawrenceville · $$ · No. 66 of 157 overall

    Wood-fired pies and natural wine; the clam pie is a sleeper. A little pricey for pizza, but worth it.

    Order: Vodka pie with hot honey

  9. 9

    Garfield · $ · No. 83 of 157 overall

    Punk-rock pizza counter that has been quietly feeding vegans and their sceptical friends for years. Order by the slice, eat it on the curb, and don't be surprised when the vegan one is the better pie.

    Order: A vegan slice that fools carnivores

  10. 10

    Bloomfield · $$ · No. 85 of 157 overall

    The owner keeps winning international pizza awards and then going back to work in Bloomfield, which is very Pittsburgh. Draft list is deeper than the room suggests.

    Order: A world-champion pie and a rare beer

Every list on this site is cut from the same board: 157 restaurants scored 1-5 by one critic, where nothing can be bought. How the ratings work →

More rankings